Why candidate feedback matters in recruitment

We live in a world of almost constant feedback, writes ema consultancy Managing Director Anne Elliott.

We are asked to rate a parcel delivery, review a meal, score a hotel stay and tell a company what we thought of its latest email. Sometimes the request arrives before we have even had time to form an opinion.

Much of this feedback is collected because organisations can collect it, rather than because it will necessarily lead to anything useful.

Yet there is one area where feedback can make a genuine difference and it is still too often overlooked: recruitment.

For someone who has invested time and energy in applying for a role, receiving nothing more than a standard rejection email can be deeply frustrating. This is particularly true after an interview or a lengthy selection process involving presentations, assessments and conversations with several people.

Candidates deserve to understand why they were unsuccessful and what they could learn from the experience.

Feedback supports development

Meaningful feedback can help candidates identify where they performed well, where they were less convincing and what they might approach differently next time.

Perhaps they had the right experience but did not explain its relevance clearly enough. Their answers may have lacked specific examples or they may not have demonstrated the strategic thinking required for the role. They might have delivered a strong presentation but struggled to engage with follow-up questions.

Without feedback, candidates are left to guess.

That can be particularly difficult for someone repeatedly reaching the interview stage, but not securing an appointment. A constructive conversation may reveal a pattern they had not recognised and give them something practical to work on.

Feedback can also build confidence. An unsuccessful candidate may assume they performed badly when, in reality, they made a strong impression but were up against someone whose experience was more closely aligned with the organisation’s immediate needs.

Feedback is not only valuable for unsuccessful candidates. It can also help the successful candidate understand the strengths they demonstrated during the selection process and begin an open discussion about areas they may wish to develop as they move into the role.

Remember understanding what they did well can be just as valuable as hearing where they need to improve.

Good feedback must be specific

Telling someone there was “a stronger candidate” may be accurate, but it is not particularly helpful.

Good feedback should deal with the specific evidence gained during the interview, rather than relying on vague generalities. It should help the candidate understand how their responses, examples or approach related to the requirements of the role.

It might explain that another candidate demonstrated more experience of leading organisational change or provided stronger evidence of working effectively with a board. Where possible, the feedback should refer to particular questions, answers or elements of the candidate’s presentation. This makes it easier for them to understand the decision and identify something practical they can take forward.

It should also distinguish between how effectively someone demonstrated their abilities during the selection process and any areas they may wish to develop over the longer term. A candidate may have the necessary ability but need to communicate it more effectively. Alternatively, the process may have identified experience or knowledge they could build before taking the next step.

Feedback should be honest, but it should also be fair and respectful. The purpose is not to produce a list of perceived shortcomings or provide an exhaustive account of everything the candidate could have done differently. It is to offer balanced, evidence-based insight that they can understand and use.

Creating the right atmosphere

One of the most important parts of giving feedback is creating a positive atmosphere for the conversation. Candidates need to feel they are in a safe and confidential space where they can listen, ask questions and discuss what they have heard. Feedback should be a conversation, not simply information delivered to them.

It is also important to acknowledge the disappointment an unsuccessful candidate may be feeling, particularly when they have gone the extra mile. They may have invested considerable time in researching the organisation, preparing a presentation, travelling to an interview or taking part in several stages of assessment. Recognising that effort and allowing space for their initial reaction can help them feel respected and make the subsequent feedback more constructive.

Feedback is usually provided by telephone or Microsoft Teams. Before going into detail, I try to understand how ready the candidate is to receive it. On the telephone, that means listening carefully to their tone and choice of words. On Teams, facial expressions and body language can provide additional clues about how they are feeling.

Giving feedback also involves listening to and observing the candidate. Sometimes the disappointment is so great that they may become upset, defensive or even angry. The person providing the feedback must judge whether the candidate is ready to receive it and adapt the conversation accordingly. Candidates should also recognise that it may be better to take some time to process the outcome before discussing the feedback in detail.

The timing matters too. Feedback is most useful when the selection process is still fresh in everyone’s mind. Keeping candidates waiting for weeks or requiring them to make repeated requests can undermine an otherwise well-managed recruitment exercise.

It is also important for employers

Providing good feedback is not simply an act of courtesy. It says something about an organisation and how it treats people.

Candidates will talk about their experience. Even those who are unsuccessful may be potential employees, board members, customers, partners or advocates in the future. A thoughtful conversation can leave someone with a positive impression despite their disappointment.

In contrast, silence or impersonal feedback can damage an organisation’s reputation. If employers expect candidates to prepare thoroughly, attend several stages and respond quickly, they should be willing to invest some time in closing the process properly.

There is also value in asking candidates for their feedback. Recruitment should be a two-way process and their perspective can help organisations identify unclear communications, unnecessary stages or elements of the assessment that did not allow people to demonstrate their abilities.

Providing feedback should also involve some self-reflection by the interviewer. Before speaking to the candidate, they should review the recruitment process, the evidence gathered and how effectively the interview allowed the candidate to demonstrate their abilities. This helps ensure the feedback reflects what actually happened during the process, is supported by clear evidence and is not influenced by personal preference or assumptions. It may also highlight questions or aspects of the selection process that could be improved for future candidates.

Making feedback part of the process

Feedback should not be treated as an optional extra to consider once an appointment has been made. It should be built into the recruitment process from the beginning.

Interview notes should capture evidence that can be shared constructively. Everyone involved in making the decision should understand who will provide feedback, how it will be delivered and when candidates can expect to receive it.

The level of feedback may reasonably reflect how far someone progressed. It may not be practical to give detailed personal feedback to every applicant at the initial stage. However, anyone invited to interview should receive more than a generic rejection.

We are surrounded by requests for feedback that may make little difference to us or to the organisation collecting it. Candidate feedback is different. Delivered well, it can help someone understand their strengths, develop their skills and approach their next opportunity with greater confidence.

That makes it more than good recruitment practice. It makes it an important investment in people.

Anne Elliot EMA Consultancy

Anne Elliott

Managing Director

07768 027837